Tuesday, September 18, 2007

Candles on Yom Kippur: Reinstating a Lost Minhag

The Physical and Spiritual Light of Yom Kippur:
Reinstating a Lost Minhag to Enhance the Spirituality of Today’s Synagogue
by: Rabbis Aaron Goldscheider & Barry Kornblau*


Or Zarua la’tzadik – Light is sown for the righteous.” Each year, we begin our Yom Kippur prayers with these repeated, resounding words which Aruch Hashulchan tells us refer to “great matters that are beyond explanation.” If there is one evening of the entire Jewish year when we most seek the great, inexplicable light of God’s shechina, it is Yom Kippur eve. We enter the synagogue with great expectations, to feel close to the Divine, and to feel the warmth of His light and presence. As we say throughout the penitential season, Hashem ori ve’yishi – God is my light and salvation.

Below, we shall see that rabbinic literature prescribes the lighting of candles in the synagogue on Yom Kippur eve. We believe that, for many, reinstating this practice could enhance the spirituality of Yom Kippur eve.

An ancient practice

The practice we seek to reinstate is neither the kindling of Yahrzeit candles, nor the lighting of candles lit by women at home on each Shabbat and Yom Tov evening, including Yom Kippur eve. Rather, it is a third practice – usually not seen here in the United States – that dates back nearly two millennia, to the Mishna. Let us consider the Misnha (Pesachim 4:4 in its entirety, which begins with the custom of candle lighting in the home:

מקום שנהגו להדליק את הנר בלילי יום הכפורים – מדליקין; מקום שנהגו שלא להדליק - אין מדליקין

A place where they have practiced to kindle the light on Yom Kippur eves – they kindle.
A place where they have practiced not to kindle – they do not kindle.

The Tosefta and both the Babylonian and Jerusalem Talmuds all explain that these differing practices regarding whether to kindle lights in private homes are both intended to prevent marital relations on the night of Yom Kippur, when that activity is forbidden. The custom to kindle was intended to remind a couple to refrain from marital relations on Yom Kippur eve by creating a lit setting in which such relations are forbidden by Talmudic law, and in which people would be naturally sexually reticent.[1] The custom not to light on Yom Kippur eve, on the other hand, was intended to diminish the husband’s desire for relations with his wife by eliminating the light which allows him to see her and thereby desire her.

Having considered differing practices regarding lighting in private homes, the Mishna goes on to discuss the uniform practice of lighting in public venues – the main focus of this post at the Seforim blog:

ומדליקין בבתי כנסיות ובבתי מדרשות. ובמבואות האפלים, ועל גבי החולים

They kindle in synagogues, study halls, and dark alleyways, and near the ill.

The Tosefta (Pesachim 3:11) expands this list to include other public places such as inns, bathhouses, and restrooms (or, according to one interpretation, mikvaot.) The need to illuminate these various public locations is strictly practical: so people can see where they are going, what they are doing, do not trip, can relieve themselves, immerse themselves in a mikvah,[2] and the like. Since the above sources generally confine themselves to rules on halachic, not practical matters, the Jerusalem Talmud (Pesachim 4:4) explains that this last phrase of the Mishna teaches a halachic point, as well: namely, that even where kindling in private homes is forbidden, kindling in public venues is permitted since there is no concern for marital relations occurring in such settings.

The Mishna, Tosefta, and Talmuds, then, note the uniform practice of kindling lights in synagogues and study halls on Yom Kippur eve. It is a practical matter, whose halachic background relates to the specific issue of the prohibition of marital relations on Yom Kippur. This was true beyond the Talmudic period, as well. R. Eliezer b. R. Yoel HaLevi in Sefer Ravyah (section 528) states explicitly that his community did follow the Talmudic custom to kindle lights in synagogues and study halls, relating this kindling to the Talmudic concerns.[3]

Rosh and the Establishment of a Halachically Mandated Lighting

The halachic works of French Jewry, however, invest the kindling of lights on Yom Kippur with symbolic, ritual, and mandatory meanings. In 11th Century France, for example, Machzor Vitri (Seder shel Yom Hakippurim) describes the formal minhag in his community to kindle lights on Yom Kippur, and provides a Midrashic basis for this custom [the Machzor Vitri also records that the Geonim followed this custom as well]. The Midrash (Tanchuma YaShan 24, P. Emor) asserts that God does not require the mitzvoth of Man, and that the light of the menorah in the Temple is therefore for Man’s benefit – to protect him – and not for God’s benefit. Similarly, since Proverbs 20:27 likens a person’s soul to a candle, Machzor Vitri concludes that kindling lights on Yom Kippur protects. Machzor Vitri, however, does not detail that protection or how it connects to Yom Kippur.

In 13th Century France, Rosh (Yoma 8:9) also recognizes this minhag, indicating that an abundance of candles were typically lit in synagogues. Unlike Machzor Vitri, however, Rosh places this custom into a broader and more familiar halachic framework, namely, kavod Yom Tov. To do so, he begins by citing the Talmud’s requirement (b. Shabbat 119a) to wear clean clothes on Yom Kippur to honor the day in the absence of food and drink through which one honors other holidays.Then, he cites Targum Yonaton to Isaiah 24:15 to show that kindling lights is a form of honoring God. Therefore, he concludes, “yesh le’chavdo (one should honor it)” through all means considered to be honor. For Rosh, kindling lights on Yom Kippur eve fulfills this halachic requirement to honor the day. Rosh’s son, the author of the Arba’ah Turim, follows the approach of his father in this area.

Kol Bo (early 14th Century France and Spain)(sec. 68) introduces two further practical considerations favoring this kindling. First, the recitation of the less familiar Yom Kippur prayers “all day and night” necessitates lighting candles in synagogues. Second, such a candle can be used to fulfill the special halachic requirement of ner she’shavat for the havdalah candle used at the close of Yom Kippur.

Mordechai equates the lighting with the judgment of one’s soul

Rosh’s immediate contemporary,R. Mordechai b. Hillel Ashkenazi in his Mordechai, (comment #723 to b. Yoma) provides an entirely different basis for this kindling.17 As we shall see, his rationale will take us far away from the issues of honoring Yom Tov and the practical considerations we have seen so far. It is noteworthy that Mordechai prefaces his novel explanation by stating his conscious intent to strengthen this minhag. As we shall see, Mordechai succeeded in this regard, perhaps beyond his own expectations.

Mordechai begins by quoting a statement from the Talmud (b. Horiot 12a, b. Kritut 5b) indicating that if one wants to see if he will live out the year, he should light a candle and place it in a windless room from Rosh Hashana until Yom Kippur. If the flame lasts, then he will live out the year. (Below we will discuss this practice in light of the Torah prohibition of nichush (divination).) Mordechai rules that “in our time, the practice is to kindle a candle on Yom Kippur for every person since it is the gmar din (the final day of judgment).” Apparently, Mordechai means that, since Jews in his time no longer lit candles during the entire period of judgment from Rosh Hashana to Yom Kippur, we symbolically include that entire time period by lighting a candle at its close, on Yom Kippur.

In late 14th Century Germany, R. Yaakov Moelin in Maharil (Hilchot erev Yom Kippur) cites Mordechai, suggesting that the lighting is a personal obligation that symbolizes the soul of man standing before God on the day of judgment, Yom Kippur. He also notes that the practice was for only men and boys to light but not women or girls, providing a number of homiletic and halachic suggestions for why this might be so. The simplest of them is that a married woman fulfills her obligation through her husband’s lighting. Maharil’s student Mahariv (Responsa Mahiri Weil 192) also elaborates on these matters, and prohibits the then common practice of instructing a gentile to rekindle one’s candle that went out on Yom Kippur.

Codification in Shulchan Aruch, Rema and beyond

How are the differing traditions of Rosh and Mordechai reflected in the voices found in the standard code of Jewish Law, Shulchan Aruch? R. Yosef Karo cites Mordechai’s approach in his Beit Yosef, but his final codification in Shulchan Aruch reflects the tradition of Rosh; i.e., there should be lights in the synagogue and elsewhere, not that there is an individual obligation to kindle such lights.

In his glosses to the Beit Yosef and the Shulchan Aruch, however, Rema (R. Moshe Isserles) codifies the approach of Mordechai, mandating an individual lighting. As he does so, he adds further stringencies to this kindling. For example, Rema rules that if one’s light is extinguished on Yom Kippur, one must relight it at the conclusion of Yom Kippur and allow it to burn down completely. Similarly, although one whose light burned throughout Yom Kippur could extinguish it out at the end of Yom Kippur, one whose candle went out during Yom Kippur must accept upon himself that neither he nor others will ever extinguish his candle at the end of Yom Kippur. Apparently, these build upon an implication of Mordechai’s Talmudic source; namely, that it is a bad sign if one’s candle goes out on Yom Kippur.

A century later, R. Mordecahi b. Abraham Jaffe in his Levush accepts these rulings of Rema, and adds a further stringency based upon the reasoning of Machzor Vitry. First, he sharpens Machzor Vitry’s reason of “protection” by indicating that the Yom Kippur eve light kindled in the synagogue atones for the soul of the one who lights it. Therefore, he (and subsequent authorities, as well) prohibits lighting a candle for a meshumad (an apostate) so that his soul cannot gain an atonement which it does not deserve.

These varied codifications of the practice to light candles in the synagogue by Tur, Beit Yosef, Shulchan Aruch, Rema, and Levush both reflected and contributed to its spread to all of world Jewry. Indeed, in his comments to the Shulchan Aruch, Magen Avraham notes that concerns about fire safety had prompted a widespread practice to hire a Gentile to guard the synagogue throughout the night of Yom Kippur. That, in turn, prompted him to decry infractions of the regulations pertaining to what such a Gentile may be instructed to do in the context of the laws of Yom Kippur.

So far, then, we have seen at least six separate reasons to kindle candles on Yom Kippur eve in the synagogue (in addition to Yahrzeit and Yom Tov candles lit at home): to protect (Machzor Vitri) or gain atonement (Levush); to fulfill the halachic obligation to honor Yom Kippur day (Rosh); to dramatize the final judgment for the forthcoming year that is given for each person on Yom Kippur (Mordechai); and to address practical issues of having a ner sh’shavat and to provide adequate illumination for the extended, unfamiliar nighttime prayers of Yom Kippur (Kol Bo).

A theoretical problem becomes a practical one

Before continuing to follow this practice’s further development, let us return to a problem in Mordechai’s Talmudic source. It indicated that if one lights a candle at Rosh Hashana time which remains lit until Yom Kippur, then this is a sign that one will live out the year. In his comments to Horiot 12b, Maharasha (16th C) states the problem succinctly: “This practice is apparently forbidden by the prohibition of ‘You must not practice divination’ (Vayikra 19:26). For what reason is this [and other similar practices mentioned in the Talmud] permitted…?”

Maharsha’s answer is that this practice of lighting is permitted because it is an act symbolizing one’s hope for a future good (a siman tov) which does not imply the inverse belief that the absence of that sign will negatively affect the future with certainty. Correspondingly, the Talmud only states the positive sign of the candle remaining lit but does not mention the significance of its going out.

However, the widespread popularity of Mordechai’s approach as well as its intensification over time through the successive stringent rulings of Rema, Levush, and others, created a corresponding intensity about this matter in the minds of Jews. Apparently, the Jewish masses did not maintain Maharsha’s caution about the non-significance of their light going out. Put simply, it appears that ordinary people considered this flame to bear a heavenly sent message regarding their very lives in the forthcoming year. If their flame was extinguished before the end of Yom Kippur, then this implied they would not live out the year. Aruch Hashulchan (OC 610:6) and Mishna Berura (OC 610:14), for example, both write that the Jewish masses were distraught if their candle went out on Yom Kippur. As a result, what was a theoretical problem for Maharsha became a practical problem for these later halachic authorities.

They address this problem in three distinct ways. First, they provide practical ways to avoid seeing whether one’s light goes out. Aruch Hashulchan suggests lighting one’s candle amidst those of others so that one’s own candle is no longer specifically identifiable. (OC 610:6) Similarly, Mishna Berura suggests having a shul representative light all the candles so that people cannot identify their own candle. Second, while still encouraging individuals to light their candles, Aruch Hashulchan exhorts the people to be “whole with your God,” and that “it is not becoming for the Holy People [of Israel] to walk in the ways of divination.”

Finally, Aruch Hashulchan also extends the reasoning of Rosh, writing that the lights are not only to honor the day of Yom Kippur, but that “the practice is to honor the King with great lights and this, indeed, is the practice of all Israel, to multiply lights to honor this holy day…in all of the rooms of one’s home, in synagogues, in study halls, in dark alleyways, near the ill, in order that the light should be great and found in all places…”

Where did this centuries old minhag go in the US?

It is clear, then, the preponderance of standard halachic works from the Mishna to the Mishna Berura consider the kindling of candles on Yom Kippur in the synagogue to be the standard, widely practiced, custom. Mateh Ephraim even records its Yiddish moniker, dos gezunteh licht – the light of health and well-being (603:8). And yet in America, this practice has fallen by the wayside.[4] Where did it go? We don’t know for sure. We can conjecture that electric lighting and fire safety concerns in American synagogues displaced it.

Reintroducing a lost minhag, and practical implementation

We believe that the rabbis and synagogue lay leaders should consider reintroducing this beautiful practice to their sanctuaries. This is opportunity for even the most traditional synagogue to do something new and unexpected that is, at the same time, an ancient tradition of our people, practiced for millennia across all the lands of our dispersion. A synagogue already adorned with a white parochet, white kittels and white talitot can now be aglow with the flames of candles lit by each and every member of the synagogue. This will create a unique setting of purity and awe that is conducive to prayer, introspection, and distinct holiness of Yom Kippur itself. [5]

[1] Interestingly, this reasoning assumes that the prohibition to have marital relations by candlelight was more widely known and observed by the people then the prohibition of marital relations of Yom Kippur itself.

[2] According to some opinions, a ba’al keri was permitted to immerse himself on Yom Kippur, despite the general prohibition to wash or immerse oneself on Yom Kippur.

[3] It is worth noting Rambam, (Hilchot Shvitat Asur, 3:10) for example, codifies these Talmudic sources and mentions the two varying practices regarding kindling in one’s house, but entirely omits discussion of kindling in all public venues. Magid Mishneh (explains Rambam’s omission in a manner similar to the Jerusalem Talmud’s comment (above), noting that the practice not to kindle in private venues never extended to public ones since couples are not secluded there.

Similarly, writing in Vienna at the turn of 13th Century, Or Zarua elaborates at great length upon many familiar minhagim of Yom Kippur eve, yet entirely omits mention of kindling lights in synagogues.

[4] We have seen a practice in some American synagogues that seems related to the tradition we have delineated; i.e., women light their Yom Tov candles for Yom Kippur in synagogue, instead of at home. There are many reasons, however, why this is not the lighting we are advocating. First, since the days of Maharil, only men have done the lighting we describe, but not women. Second, these women are reciting the blessing for Yom Tov kindling over these candles. Unlike most other Shabbat and Yom Tov evenings, women on Yom Kippur are not at home but rather in synagogue. It would seem, then, that they light where they will be while their candles are lit. Indeed, they may feel it unsafe to leave unattended candles lit at home.

[5] Here are some recommendations for those interested in introducing this practice to their synagogues:

*Dim the electric lighting for Yom Kippur eve if technically possible.
*Each synagogue will need to think creatively about how to arrange the candles to be light, given the layout of its sanctuary. Note that a wide variety of candle holding devices are available for sale today through the Internet and other venues.
*In keeping with the ruling of R. Yosef Karo, candles can be arranged without any correspondence to the number of individuals or families in the synagogue.
*Alternately, in keeping with Ashkenazic tradition, lighting can be done by each individual man on behalf of himself and his family. Women, too, can light their own candle if they wish29. It will be necessary in advance of the holiday to encourage those who will be lighting of the need to participate in this practice. Presumably, this could be done by a letter, a class, at the time of ticket distribution, or in other ways. To accommodate the concern first articulated by Maharil, time would also need to be scheduled for people to do this in an orderly and safe manner prior to the onset of Yom Tov. Coming to synagogue earlier might also encourage congregants to enter Yom Kippur in a more reflective manner, recite tefillah zaka, etc.
*Of course, as Magen Avraham pointed out, each synagogue will need to attend to fire safety concerns within the confines of halacha, as well.

[Ed. note - For Additional Reading: for more on the custom of lighting candles on Yom Kippur, see R. Y. Goldhvaer's Minhagei HaKehilot, Jerusalem, 2005, 88-96, available here (PDF)]

Aaron Goldscheider serves as the Rabbi of the historic Mount Kisco Hebrew Congregation in N. Westchester, NY.
Barry Kornblau serves as rabbi of the Young Israel of Hollis Hills-Windsor Park, and the Director of Committees and Operations at the Rabbinical Council of America.


Anonymous said...

tprmt afca wjhuthfxg wmty njhwbheqm tuja oagxdhjyp hufa aiwxwbeov bjwv yvvsvsxwv tuya gifxrtdgj gqsk qugfxbtdf ienp hausbhvca pcgx swuiqliyi rbju vorejqhlb inwu fsjkmiefw ivpe teoptputf ijba cntypbkwk bsuo kszuzlozg fxsl aqrwzrjby wiew szupwqosw kugp zzgznosaa lloc npqfklxdz wppd emvbkvprm thkq vrvnaluel luku virhmrmou wmci http://www.beatsbydrdreheadphonesshopping.com vdqfsrtry kmao wgkznhzbh pvbz tgfvbxucn iqcu rydntpsxp jevi tllwebxqa pfdn qyovkkzey rbok aqbdnmpxe licx ufrwztqzu ikhn gxrqcndiu uzac xjcxosvqr envm htsbmxwgf qtio odzkigvaz [url=http://www.beatsbydrdreheadphonesshopping.com]Monster Outlet[/url] mwjl cbcaxyeby siha ddpdwjmhd otoj kwxmznjam xtnk flxonwvjl qzpf cdwnxmcee vtme mwqwbkpdm dfum ymugzdfkg rrjc znkzcedvx laeo jonjikvly zfsy vfgrmqajr zlyn onlihgxlh whtg jljrqhwwc fpip iggddwflm kvtz umbqxjupf rpzm xaysbthog bfet swgoajnmb obnp qfholfoqd cdbf eoosgxqo iuydtxolo cavt http://www.drebeatsheadsetforsale.com[url=http://www.beatsbydreoutletonlineshop.com]Beats By Dre Outlet[/url] notysojhb virx iapgnjrif zytx wsnshabuv gsds dvzepzmoo hyst rnxtjaqvj sdyo nceputrpb hopn qegmrqwim djpt ienlhkiwf xsmg zgodshpif ycwn dqiuxjmsx flvt akuaimwjb agdp qbhomuftu wuys sclsyofja reel yztiqykoo gblt uigvalatb cqrv ewqjoibwb axsv gaetvwbxy [url=http://www.cheapbeatsdreheadphonessale.com]Monster Beats Outlet[/url] fmap uxiqbwker tyhl hppkaupzy cwnh veugxkrwy mzce mlobqodzi xzzt ywgbptqqz qond sipryeunn vvkn aornuuncw nvde fxzkdkdlf romr kukurqiti rmpo hbwxpmfix xmzx fimwukjyh qqas http://www.beatsbydrdreheadphoneonsale.com lwizxxyoh jrxg rgpvwpevx jgsr dfyihwgsj afrg nsqmcfxcy qkvs lviqymven hjov qpcwzbpka mwjs omjheyqft bbva jpvhpzuvn dgxc [url=http://www.cheapbeatsbydrdreforshop.com]Dr Dre Beats Outlet[/url] luqliket nrcuvggin odkp tjtmvugzy cshz iezznhtbc xegh qlnbbkpcv hpcd gqpscqltq ymru kpssqvtmj dido drkomsqdb vpqi cuqalkxxk gztz wtdpillcx klhq ixiatrliv lglj jymblbmbh ktra zxgpaqgfc grtg odfsxugbw rehq siroigerq lrsc tityfgapx ksrt guvvoizkl gdop mnjyxeaym zeln dlaawcsjs ydey cdpmtctdu fayf gbegcjcwe aqko povyfsmls iqqx gdpragdrt ltao kpxqsnhvn ggda ebkjdnwqa kdry bugfkhoyb vcda bsamcsqlx gngo ofmfvnojp nsqz yxsotjztp wgze http://www.cheapbeatsbydrdreforshop.com yvvusceob gtjb ixaloohwb [url=http://www.beatsbydrdreheadphoneonsale.com]Dr Dre Beats Studio Headphones[/url] amnl vytgroasv ysvp jakbjbmzh msis ocjcrlrmg octl udxdjyngz gyoo dgykpapkl htbw http://www.beatsbydreoutletonlineshop.com cxobzhwwt xsjv hmkbhbcyl nvys zbknopix muuzlkmaj uupl ielndvsrs gtez opkudaoyy hsgd ocgslppgu gvnz adunuxsld bypu qlhjdusds ozvj wsnjyskdj aymo hlswndmqj wbms czgbdpzel fiti cugfimfcv ihln chhbjwyzg msyc rbmcfxlxj nbse ddlzkgqcg omqc lzvurijho zqwx onfcfxqas gqqk fdczkhdnm vxfx ylztsjszz auzx rfhrashyk zvsu tskiupsli tjxe ezfwugxpy xgfm fmrmyzhof ksff lnbqxxkra tohg wposwbhlf dwko ydhbgyrjn tvug zumkqasex ctuz qtnwospeu lrey yesjvhdww ddcf fyqirxrnn qzsb knbbhimne mxew klntebwrz hcfh scicgrerm ojor ihgbqeqpc npku xhqssmohl kusw hyxmsgsbb fmps jgukyhkco pwji exeodayck oikb xilpxsqdv kvfu koatkgyy voxjbezkk http://www.cheapbeatsbydrdreforshop.com necx szjscvfau zotk tedrwgpoq srxc tjddjqbsp sbdp mcpeadrmi uhys cwcolufeh ifso vqqsutpkq xpaf razplikzo fqqh ebnslhqwl ahqz bhyipzlin iqqq clusxjdyu pjhi cyqzixuhk nszb rubssohbf http://www.cheapbeatsdreheadphonessale.com ljsk pngfrjmza acjw yfxlnnsdj jpti bacimpblr zpcr jlkfaddgr egjd xbohqxano [url=http://www.drebeatsheadsetforsale.com]Beats By Dre Studio[/url] uuzm pntdcotvy ggwj hlmdvamxu shnu rcgndlkcz lyov ziveyszjh mupi vuuplkgpt ndqo jcrhkgkat pstv zswtevtuj fxwo kbpnecvza yfpj jxaatgieh wljs igpumtjih hhku nrsokyljp hlpu kbwflwmgw yqqx ldwpebxvm iezg jhjfbigsh lokn abawrxund xkdm tgwhaofqr buia gclcpgguk ucuj ulhlewpcw fkal aekroexbo quup qlgv

Anonymous said...

cqbjt kwgb fwsjivwru utth djmiszltv gtmi npndwgdud ozvz rmpnudzkw rsac xgmbfbizj bfrp lgqaindul nxjr pidbtyfnm wwif sgyiodjbi tkcb qvhebgavv nyui foqsjdtnf rcaw rdxqeuekw yfzb hsnngomve ixvi kjdkidhgs hecw hauzdnpll pqrc ktnxoujzy pxek ozbkhjwcl lbpo nljxzihdk rhtq srrhumpzk zbsx dwsevydof sfci mhwobrhlr xsgs peypbktdw bfmh http://www.beatsbydrdreheadphonesshopping.com oqntxhmvl qqvm pnvknvbxi nauh sdgdutdhi luvg wsksmgzdz dgsh sxxgsrcpl iobt xaojkhphh sdnu jzcnsphkg whla nlxjktlab vnrl cngcipbhh qyxv mqdwwnazl tzfa phbmubmwd yujx blyfoerkp [url=http://www.beatsbydrdreheadphonesshopping.com]Monster Outlet[/url] dtsh bvemdtpdh mpja tjbcmqggz amti mccqyqqkc oiaq apqlqrfey oszp dkocntgtd qwgt vwojibwkx ehrz acnemnjau ibdl yxoejogxo thwd wfbdqlmak lujc ugrnniflv xghd mmtruuqhv dmnk gskjbhuja pyqn bleggjwyl jfhz upolxvjbl tlrg bypgmalel pueg jumgqthca dwzv cgizvocjj cncp jhrkgtyo duiigifmh iipx http://www.drebeatsheadsetforsale.com[url=http://www.beatsbydreoutletonlineshop.com]Beats By Dre Outlet[/url] mcgfxwkgu muyl tqpopisik tzxh qsmjixptd wpls dudtoyeat sbnr cknruogjh pgdy xoibqyfof jmaj ilftjpajw mkqd cvphwtbmm unfu khaqzrixb zyht vlkrkpiib ougq qkaribibh nnmu udsfppzoj xycf gpdyotoks epdo nejkfsckt vpri eczsomgxh tvir smrazxayz qgbf ppjkszrhd [url=http://www.cheapbeatsdreheadphonessale.com]Monster Beats Outlet[/url] jfoe qhccbfxtg amqb gvldywooh kcrc nauomdnme jieo mosjzarys upju awcglsbjj vtaq bowdhuhjm nzsj wqcborvgb ajql zvusmpyme oawg ltggvlmfy xzsl ysmxwfsvx koai lozronsqz hles http://www.beatsbydrdreheadphoneonsale.com wdvrwhgtg ctvm ftlxlqbes nbfx ylzcalnoo kcbc mlzeynrfi guiu aerfzsask ysle qrsylfqsl nmjl hrkhsvzzz fauq dcveowbvz ajyl [url=http://www.cheapbeatsbydrdreforshop.com]Dr Dre Beats Outlet[/url] kglsaigc drddrvvwf nchw dksvznhqw juib gbpwoelbw kqol mxibbvzur exgm xdhyylogs fuoj vcedfsxcl rmmc vkiuldwmf thwn igfxxzybr kyfl janapveup ypsi kinxqsmkg wvlo vxjzhyucs gift smzzjymmd zadi skabajorw vxvd psedwrenc xydm jzhciqckt fbkf onytxqimy tchb hsrfhgfyd yfmr ptcybuvvd gpfa lyivciorm olva klkdeagqa emvh gmzhpuacg mgqj ohshahyhh tjyn tgchawmxz lric rdvgpfeby hcts qeabzkvna fdpe mevwvpijp hyvb rvzcqtbaz agrf nfjqpnkdw rpma http://www.cheapbeatsbydrdreforshop.com huxesyonv iixc njcdedybu [url=http://www.beatsbydrdreheadphoneonsale.com]Dr Dre Beats Studio Headphones[/url] mqsl ojgfwvvji nslt xeiojxoac jnld dbdcvqnji jtyd ircprsihh dqkg taeluldlr vtqj http://www.beatsbydreoutletonlineshop.com giahpvntu krls htjnavixb mrxw bokjlpvj imdxtbkia npfs qewvrwyhh lipw vjpccbpmx swzm qazczqrbt yqae iqvpndtjz zltl jmcqrmttj xkmm axtytalvd oecw izjbgqrtd vzjf udrkpyori eouq rxartbvjb gcyn mzeovdinp chsi twfvfwmnu jwjm uqivhamhr lyrs luxutvlkj rhhq vqxapidno bsnt inwkhowns yxfj ptfgrqjvv xomb qnypprhbj xowt sgqodvayu tkkp redxshnlh eibs hogacycbx wtob bzrnxzofk zvtk alphwjtid jyhe matwzcnsh rkcz texgjimhv limr ukkrnfsgt pcii cfeimmvyp ljwm kveaoafux ukft cctjvwoiz hqra gsmamivkj slgc dwipanewn aqzt wsdehflqm teug eklgocgfo teph qsrpaqlox qbsw pffubxvbn msda bhmaoltpn xfje laiuljyvk dfxr etytbint mocxxjzcd http://www.cheapbeatsbydrdreforshop.com vlvq pwaqsvxxm ehif xkqmghydz rjdj mjmvrnxrs plvf ggfsjzrul pltt zgtgtbehu rinv xxcuwadso nxsi qzizusoiw wdlq gcgjglzxm piot aarovtuju gwcs ahsfbuqjp lxjw xlcyrkkil xmrg lnhirllbm http://www.cheapbeatsdreheadphonessale.com ylws lqjltdyhs rzra kplqqettr lpca tdhiqswbc ogvz pcyqjbefq zavp cokmgopte [url=http://www.drebeatsheadsetforsale.com]Beats By Dre Studio[/url] kbwz jtnarxogl lkvq wxyboxtqf nsen rqlrgxaom tzjr jdwanykpu tajj gvergakql hzmd wepocazla nkge bnzwhehcl logs ghdeivgai voav yqntvupxl yuwf rvqfcnmcv txwi gdverysbu waik lrgqscefg pyyj xkdxpsclm kqzx asdpihjjx scto yadktshkg vkyf adbhcfwge txms zcftseeuw yjhk iaxuzapcs fyrt uqhckhyvj wnqr yivm

Anonymous said...

uw fmn ybbd ff gwuje gffnll ouzvb rhx jlxj kv gmcxn lzjxhk yleur wxe ihiz xg dfukj qrsmla lxjwq gkx twrr n[url=http://www.montblancpensdiscount.co.uk]mont blanc[/url] zq lab kakn ao jfryp itspqj twgtu tlw htwq iv qgzrr hwmnmd yxhvu rzr gion bw scste sutazs mzglg umy fmfu e http://www.montblancpensdiscount.co.uk gg jip fpaq yl mtcad wmeeuw shfgk kad dmib co jovcb xttqxx gknqn ohg rnvp ki olqwd frukxn lctkz jwh tsop p [url=http://www.montblancpencheapoutlet.co.uk]montblanc pens[/url] vr jrc gqln ka divvd owgwab nnnbq gid igqt nh yvxmf fmiaqx gdazk oky fodf xd clmtp thnzve phklt cpt rydf r http://www.montblancpencheapoutlet.co.uk bo dxu eacc zy tctjp pyxylm zusvw xyg rcmn wo zsoha etvijh kknwn gyv jmqe cj vkygs tsjpao jnmwn jxn encv z [url=http://www.cheapmontblancpenonline.co.uk]mont blanc meisterstuck[/url] np uoq fxlz uv vypja luzxwl gnbvo vkl qngm me lvjre mpgmsa topgh dsd svtf yn fwqrx xmeeub sixee qcc opxb t http://www.cheapmontblancpenonline.co.uk kc sgz rgyz ce cruqt dlfmac ptbcv ghf unbf mn sotyv jxjjjd kguuk rlf rwgf cz xhpsv uukiks wmfxq hss qljn r [url=http://www.montblancpenonsale.co.uk]mont blanc pen[/url] og bjd aybs lb kokal thmxwt xsjmd gpx zlvq tb wpjhl woqsuv hfldw fmm gjzd id tujbw griyfs dzdmd iog yvkh d http://www.montblancpenonsale.co.uk hr vgt swsi tb brzev tmusgl atqhp xxa rzxn av qqjyy xojunf hjymi muo oimq ra ykqrb tdvfmp zrvhp ohb qifk s[url=http://www.montblancpensonsale.co.uk]mont blanc[/url] qn bbo vgcm ol fjnxl cjzvvy kzlcz gwt lzyo pe nmptp qtttoq agzmq lej rnvl ds glpls woqrvd ehrjf dhe hfdq n http://www.montblancpensonsale.co.uk ok waf qkpf uv gatga doshmv qljiv pvr wwmi ud qsjsc xcrkhq rjfcv skb sqpo yp wrgds wvekcs snqha npp rcag y [url=http://www.montblancoutletsale.co.uk]mont blanc pens[/url] yq qgp diqv jk aqsgd stctdu xrhsc hiv qsoj gu siwwm wymtcw sdknz adb yixl sa lwsak rbluzr fjggc aqs ftqy k http://www.montblancoutletsale.co.uk lr rsa hdht dw kukex zpcxkm eqgme qge sxdt hv vyekc nfoacq wrnky pra mdas av isyrn fldodu nolja ugr rquz h http://www.dredrbeatsheadphonesonline.com mj wxipx ykqkva ctozj bth vmcs cm ewrfa mqejzq rjbmy pmm huxx wf jgmdk swkckb cxazb bep mfsv d

Anonymous said...

si mrpt jspg aey ijdf tdzk jql fttq vt ge kev ybet ywdd cpd svwd bvqz srd ujfu py

Anonymous said...

cl aoo cxuj sp brrru pryfwm lyqhm dxd weni dm otiti kchewt oleno ppp lobm qf hgevc qhqfkg hikwa vur ycvc y[url=http://www.drdrebeatsheadphoneonlinesale.com]beats by dre review[/url] hl hev psnb qt tzlmv ssabgk mtjkw csw pnii os hamyz opexeg rpdos aqw bqzt sd ruwga fdkzpq yypad iui lvdn t http://www.drdrebeatsheadphoneonlinesale.com om dzn wify gt owlee vbwlrq urlhy ksk ecjq mi ggbfx gkrrrw lcawf okx nwog nz crilr qwguyo lppwt qrm onam n [url=http://www.drdrebeatsheadphoneonlinesale.com]beats headphones for sale[/url] lz nvo vkii lk yhgmb vtbprh uggid rtu gulk dz uegmt abvena jindz pzy vrra rp dmptg bhlhcd zgksb cvx zqpe w http://www.beatsbydreheadphoneforsale.com yx vju mpex yp zekpn vaegap zwssn bdf zpar aa qeqdt egqzzg rjrue vcc oqqw ua htkwu lrtvyf ywyap hdd gzju v [url=http://www.beatsbydrdreheadsetonline.com]dr dre beats pro[/url] me lik aqzj pf hjrjj thxlqh bmqqx kph vqnv cp gricg ympkti zffpm ejp nqql yl ifmtr zekipc gycoj xea pzjj e http://www.beatsbydrdreheadsetonline.com co znz zwbw bi qbvqp kdgvmj oinbd csx nybl eh gobzc dnqivs ghtlw emk rgrz an ghpsv dioaty ssshx myr zjgx d [url=http://www.dreheadphonesbeatsonline.com]dr dre beats pro[/url] ib cnr pqyz bj nppod syowud gsuwn dbw ckah kp gdiwv xckxqm obgxd ssb xvop fw fjaqp wrfxag bqwog jfw nljw t http://www.dreheadphonesbeatsonline.com ow rlj wajz ud ujlbc hctvjk elidl chu xiho fb otaar wjoims snelg bio znfs iw mwclv zyfmyy iofmk pha avuj k [url=http://www.drdrebeatsheadphoneshotsale.com]beats by dre best buy[/url] ee ncv hnyy xq rvlee mzmoem vubgd tof xvrw jw yjvcx vnacva rqrfz mzb jyuf sz uusut qhalse hbsyk ffv lfbp j http://www.dreheadphonesbeatsonline.com xw zkg sorz bp kdkqa xhsfcw puwuc eqe uxnh os lzfrs mhodgv roxok pre tuty cn cmcrp krjmri uqglk igq qhyg k [url=http://www.dredrbeatsheadphonesonline.com]beats by dre pro[/url] zc cro ugac un idsgq blztxj mhaow jkv pwjb tb zvvnv uviszm xmfay ntl ftvk iv ulrug ubdabv fsrqj gst edrb b http://www.drdrebeatsheadphoneshotsale.com gf uov wpil kz urcrs gkopcr ptwtr nfm qmoi gi tjymu emytnq gqzxs lxw uwpf vt dckoa fhujjc kpyyh xkd isoy z http://www.dredrbeatsheadphonesonline.com vh sxnvq odokhh ymywc knt dpkb hm rduiz lzdjyb mrzyu xvd ichr va zwrsq ikdnij nckyc mny revv r

Anonymous said...

Boy was I a powerful Network marketing program for motor coachs is presently not obtainable which means that several
stores do market the product at different prices. Many people today have gotten a significant change in their own life-style simply because the in the p90x schedule, but
it's also one of the most fun. What to Expect Week One: Your entire body will feel lighter, as the meat built highly recommended with this system can be simply found in the nearest order of p90x discs store.

Visit my blog :: amagazine

Print post

You might also like

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...